Artificial Justice Speaker Series - Virtual Lecture with Shira Gur-Arieh
"Ambiguity Collapse by LLMs: A Taxonomy of Epistemic Risks"
Wednesday, 2 December 2026, 2:00 p.m. - 3:00 p.m. (CET)
About the Speaker:
Shira Gur-Arieh is a doctoral candidate at Harvard Law School and an affiliate at the Berkman-Klein Center for Internet and Society. Her research examines how the use of AI in legal institutions affects the legitimacy of their decisions. Her work has received the Reidenberg Award for Outstanding Scholarship, the Best Paper Award at We Robot, and an Honorable Mention for Best Paper at ACM FAccT. Shira holds an LL.M. from Harvard Law School and an LL.B. from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. She previously clerked for Chief Justice Esther Hayut of the Supreme Court of Israel.
About the Topic:
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used to make sense of ambiguous, open-textured, value-laden terms. Platforms routinely rely on LLMs for content moderation, asking them to label text based on disputed concepts like “hate speech” or “incitement”; hiring managers may use LLMs to rank who counts as “qualified”; and AI labs increasingly train models to self-regulate under constitutional-style ambiguous principles such as “biased” or “legitimate”. This talk introduces ambiguity collapse: a phenomenon that occurs when an LLM encounters a term that admits multiple legitimate interpretations, yet produces a singular resolution, in ways that bypass the human practices through which meaning is ordinarily negotiated, contested, and justified. Drawing on interdisciplinary accounts of ambiguity as a productive epistemic resource, we develop a taxonomy of the epistemic risks posed by ambiguity collapse at three levels: process (foreclosing opportunities to deliberate, develop cognitive skills, and shape contested terms), output (distorting the concepts and reasons agents act upon), and ecosystem (reshaping shared vocabularies, interpretive norms, and how concepts evolve over time). For this talk, I focus on how these risks arise in law and what is at stake given the distinctive institutional role ambiguity plays there. I will conclude by sketching multi-layer mitigation principles spanning training, institutional deployment design, interface affordances, and the management of underspecified prompts, with the goal of designing systems that surface, preserve, and responsibly govern ambiguity.
About the Speaker Series:
The Artificial Justice Speaker Series features guests working at the intersection between law, computer science, and the humanities. Neither technical nor juristic knowledge is a prerequisite for participation—the Series is aimed at anyone with an interest in critical and interdisciplinary perspectives on “Law and AI”. The event takes place on Zoom and is scheduled to last one hour.
Max Planck Institute for Comparative and International Private Law
- Mittelweg 187, 20148 Hamburg, Deutschland
- veranstaltungen@mpipriv.de
- (+49 40) 41900 - 0
- mpipriv.de